AI hiring tools could be costing you more than you think

Support from an HR consultant in Raleigh on what the new AI hiring rules require and how to keep your hiring process compliant.

As a business owner, you’ve probably adopted software that helps sort through job applicants without giving it a second thought.

That software may now come with legal obligations you haven’t heard about.

A handful of states and cities have passed laws that hold employers responsible for how automated hiring tools treat candidates. And the responsibility sits with you, even if you didn’t build the tool.

Here’s what you need to know and what to do about it.

Where the rules stand right now

These regulations aren’t theoretical. Several are already in effect, and the landscape is still shifting.

New York City was one of the first to act. If you’re using automated tools to evaluate job candidates there, you’re required to have an independent bias audit done each year, publish a summary of the results, and tell candidates that the tool is being used. Fines start at $500 per violation and can reach $1,500 per day.

Illinois followed with its own law, effective January 2026. Employers must tell applicants and employees when AI is involved in decisions around hiring, promotions, or discipline. If the tool produces outcomes that disproportionately affect a protected group, the employer is responsible, even without knowing about the problem. The state is still finalizing the rules on how notice has to be given, but the obligation itself is already in effect.

California’s civil rights regulations, in effect since October 2025, treat an employer’s use of automated decision tools the same as any other employment practice under state anti-discrimination law.

Colorado’s law takes effect January 1, 2027. It was scaled back this year and now focuses on notifying candidates, giving them a route to human review, and keeping records, rather than requiring impact assessments.

Not every state is moving in the same direction. A federal court blocked enforcement of Colorado’s original law earlier this year, and the federal government is actively challenging state AI rules. So the picture is unsettled, and it’s worth watching rather than assuming it will resolve one way or the other.

What this means if you’re hiring in North Carolina

North Carolina doesn’t have an AI hiring law of its own. But that doesn’t mean these rules don’t reach you.

If you hire remotely and a candidate is located in Illinois, Colorado, California, or New York City, that jurisdiction’s rules can apply to how you evaluated them. And if your job postings are visible to applicants in those places, the disclosure requirements may apply to the posting itself.

Federal law applies everywhere. If an automated tool screens out candidates from a protected group, that’s a potential claim under Title VII regardless of what state you’re in. Private lawsuits on exactly that theory are already moving through the courts.

Why you’re probably more exposed than you realize

Most business owners don’t look at their applicant tracking system and think “artificial intelligence.” But if that system scores resumes, ranks candidates, or filters people out automatically, it almost certainly qualifies under these laws.

The bigger issue is liability. You might assume that because a vendor sold you the software, they carry the risk. They don’t. As the employer using the tool to make hiring decisions, the legal responsibility sits with you.

It doesn’t matter that you had no role in designing the algorithm. It doesn’t matter that you were unaware it was screening candidates unfairly. The law treats you as the decision-maker because you chose to use the tool.

That’s a real risk for a small business, and one that many owners don’t know they’re carrying.

A practical checklist you can work through this week

You don’t need to overhaul everything overnight, but there are concrete steps you can take right now.

  • Catalog every tool involved in your hiring workflow.Go beyond just your main applicant tracking system. Include resume screening software, skills assessments, video interview platforms, and any vendor-provided tools that influence which candidates advance. If it plays any role in deciding who moves forward, write it down.
  • Contact each vendor and ask direct questions. Find out whether their product has undergone independent bias testing. Ask for documentation. If a vendor can’t provide a straightforward answer, that tells you something important about the risk you’re taking on by continuing to use their product.
  • Audit your candidate-facing communications. Depending on where your applicants are located, you may already be required to disclose that AI is part of your evaluation process. Review your job postings, application forms, and any correspondence with candidates to confirm you’re meeting disclosure obligations.
  • Start keeping detailed records. Document which tools you use, what bias testing has been completed, and what information you’ve shared with candidates. If a complaint is ever filed, your ability to show a clear paper trail will matter enormously.

Your hiring managers need to be in the loop

The people posting job openings and deciding how to screen applicants are often the same people selecting which tools to use. If they don’t know the obligations attached to automated hiring technology, gaps will open up with every new role.

Make sure the people involved in your hiring process know which tools require candidate disclosures. They should also understand what documentation needs to be maintained and how to respond if a candidate asks about the evaluation process.

This isn’t a one-time training conversation. As state laws change, the requirements will shift. Your managers need to stay informed, and you need a system for keeping them updated.

Questions worth sitting with

Take a few minutes to consider where your business stands:

  • Could you produce a complete list of every automated tool involved in your hiring process right now?
  • Have you confirmed with each vendor that their product has been independently tested for bias?
  • Do your job postings and application materials include the disclosures required in the states where you hire?
  • If a candidate filed a complaint tomorrow, would your records show what tools were used and what candidates were told?

If you answered “no” or “I’m not sure” to any of those, you’ve got some work to do. And you’re far from alone.

How we help with this

We look at your full hiring process, from the tools you’re using to the way you communicate with candidates to the records you’re keeping. Our HR consulting services in Raleigh include identifying exactly where your exposure is and helping you close those gaps before they become problems.

We check your vendor relationships to confirm whether the right testing and documentation are in place. We review your candidate communications to make sure you’re meeting disclosure requirements. And we help you build a recordkeeping system that will hold up if it’s ever scrutinized.

Getting ahead of this takes far less time and money than responding to a complaint.

If you’re using automated tools in your hiring process and haven’t reviewed where you stand, now is a good time.

We provide outsourced HR consulting in Raleigh and across the country, and we’re here to walk you through it. Book a discovery call with our team and we’ll help you figure out exactly where you stand.

I'd like to receive free HR advice to my inbox each month!