The best way to avoid an employment lawsuit

Defending an employment claim is expensive well before it reaches trial. Legal fees, document production, depositions, and the hours you and your managers spend on it instead of running the business. And that’s separate from any settlement.

A lot of those claims started as something small. A concern that got brushed aside. A complaint that sat too long. A conversation someone kept meaning to have.

By the time an employee is talking to an attorney, you’re past the point where this could have been resolved with a conversation.

The most cost-effective thing you can do isn’t a policy. It’s building a workplace where problems get raised early, handled properly, and resolved before anyone needs a formal process.

What that actually looks like

People say “open culture” a lot without saying what it means. In a small business, it means four things:

  • People trust that raising a concern won’t cost them anything
  • Managers know how to listen and respond proportionately, even when it’s uncomfortable
  • There’s a simple, informal way to raise something before it becomes a formal complaint
  • When someone raises something, it actually gets addressed

That last one is the whole thing. A reporting process nobody trusts is worse than not having one, because now people have tried and learned it doesn’t work.

Why it’s worth attention now

In FY2025, the EEOC recovered $660 million for workers, including $528 million through pre-litigation enforcement. That’s the highest pre-litigation recovery in the agency’s 60-year history.

Charge filings are up too. The agency received 91,503 new discrimination charges last year, a 3.4% increase.

Most of that money moved during the investigation stage, before anyone saw a courtroom. Which tells you where these things get decided, and it isn’t in a trial.

What to actually do

  • Train your managers on early, honest conversations. This is where problems either get resolved or get worse.
  • Build regular one-on-ones into the rhythm of the business. Short and frequent beats long and occasional.
  • Create a simple informal route for concerns. People should know how to raise something without it feeling like they’ve filed a complaint.
  • Act on what you hear. Nothing kills a speak-up culture faster than feedback that goes nowhere.
  • Write down conversations and agreed actions. Not as a paper trail. So you both remember what you agreed to, and so it holds up if anyone asks later.

How we can help

We work with small businesses on the kind of workplace where problems surface early. That includes manager training on difficult conversations and building simple processes people will actually use.

If there’s a team issue you’ve been putting off, it gets more expensive the longer it sits. And usually harder, too.

Get in touch for a confidential conversation.

I'd like to receive free HR advice to my inbox each month!